Last night, Jim and I headed to Mohegan Sun Casinos for a much-anticipated double-bill concert of Damien Rice and Fiona Apple.
Now, I have gone on record as saying that I prefer my women musicians somewhat crazy; they’re just more interesting when they’re a little transgressive and impolite. But the damn chicks keep going overboard with it, and going full-tilt bug-out loony on me (See Exhibit A: Sinead O’Connor).
Last night Fiona Apple was so unbelievably bad that we might need PTSD therapy.
She started out a bit wobbly-voiced, which is not unusual — I’ve read that she has stage fright, and I’ve seen her twice before and know that after she gets comfortable, her voice evens out and she goes on to deliver the goods. Usually, that is.
Last night, she sounded like she was channeling Yoko Ono, and not in a good way (Wait. IS there a good way?). She shrieked and snarled in only the barest approximation of the melody, and while I certainly welcome a musician reimagining their music, this was more like a murder than a reinvention. When she wasn’t shrieking incoherently into the microphone, she was turned to her bandmates and roadies, shouting abuse at them. Their tense, head-down demeanor reminded me of emotional abuse victims, and I wondered how long she’d been at it.
And then there was the physical aspect of her performance. Between the spastic twitching, smacking herself in the head, and staggering around with her hair over her face, she seemed to be channeling the wraith from The Ring, except really coked up.
I have NEVER been so tense during a concert; it was an actively unpleasant experience. I think her handlers need to be thinking about therapy for her before she hurts herself, and/or someone needs to smack her and tell her to stop acting like a one year old.
If, as her legions of fans claim on her site, she was just pissed off about a bad sound mix, well, there are better ways to handle that. Such as, perhaps, turning to her techie and asking, “Um, can you help me out here?”
But I don’t buy that excuse. The opener sounded OK, and Damien sounded absolutely GORGEOUS. Besides, if the techies set your levels for how you usually sing and then you go all ape$h!t on them and start singing like a cadaver, I think it would stand to reason that the mix would sound off.
In any case it was the most unprofessional display I’ve seen, and that includes the Ryan Adams concert where he spent 5 minutes futzing onstage with the barrette in his hair. At least when HE got around to playing, the music didn’t sound like my cats beating each other up.
Anyway, the evening wasn’t a total loss, because as I said, Damien delivered the goods. Part of the fine Irish tradition of beautiful noise, he delivered a stunning interpretation of the whole wall of sound. Several times he’d begin songs as quiet folk medlodies strummed on acoustic guitar while he and his duet partner sang in achingly lovely voices, and then they added a cello, drums, bass, and then, WHOMP! he’d hit some sort of switch, trip the guitar into scary eletric mode, and just wail away.
If you’ve never heard him before, you must check out “O,” his first album, forthwith, in particular ‘I Remember,” which is a stunning little mini-opera of a relationship that ends with the best bassline EVER.